Episode
The Gatekeeper
Unedited Chats
John: I'm excited about this series because I think that well, here's my goal. I never, ever, ever, ever want to be caught telling you what to think. Ever. But I do want to give you freedom and permission to think. And I think so often that's been stifled in the church context where we're just supposed to go to the buffet and eat what's served. But I want you to use wisdom. I want you to use the the gifts that God has already planted in your life to be able to discern what is truth. Okay? Fair? Okay. So this week we're gonna get into more of how our Western theology has been shaped. Theology, for those of you who may be wondering, what is this gibberish she's speaking? It just means what is your belief about God? And so theology is just easier to say than what is our belief about God? But what we believe about God is the absolute most important thing about you. If you believe about God that He is angry and distant, guess how you're going to treat every relationship in your life? With anger and distance. It's just the reality. What you believe about God is the most important thing about you. My hope. Is that I can get you to rethink what you think you know about God. Because there's a lot of things that we have just taken. Yes, we've just swallowed it as biblical. There's a scene worth imagining before we get to any of the men whose names carry this history. Roman soldiers standing guard outside a tomb, spears in hand, making sure nothing gets out. That image is going to matter more than it seems right now. Hold on to it. Because somewhere along the way, a gospel that began as an open door became something guarded instead. Not maliciously, not by villains twirling mustaches in the dark, by ordinary men. Reaching for the best language their era gave them, trying to explain something too large for words, and building brick by brick a courtroom where a homecoming used to be. It starts, as so much of the series does, with an emperor. In the year three hundred thirteen, Constantine legalized Christianity. By three hundred eighty, under Theodosius, it was no longer merely tolerated, it was the empire's official religion. In one long generation, The church went from being hunted to being handed the keys. Eusebius, the bishop who wrote Constantine's biography, records the emperor saying something remarkable at a banquet with church leaders. You are bishops of those within the church, but I have been appointed by God bishop of those outside. He didn't convert to the church's terms, he installed himself as its overseer and From that point forward, the gospel starts running an imperial logic instead of the other way around. That's not a metaphor, that's the actual moment the software changed. Not long after, Augustine of Hippo picked up a mistranslated line from Romans Romans five, a Latin rendering that made it sound like all humanity sinned in Adam rather than as a consequence of Adam's fall, and built an entire anthropology on top of it. In his handbook, he describes the whole human race as a mass under condemnation, wallowing in misery, paying the well-merited penalty of the impious rebellion. Every baby on this reading arrives already owing a debt it never personally incurred. Not sick, not wounded, guilty from the very first breath. Seven centuries later, Anselm of Canterbury took that guilt and gave it an accounting system. He lived in a feudal world where honor was currency, and offending a lord offending a Lord meant either repayment or punishment. There was no third option. He mapped that world directly on to God. The honor taken away must be repaid, or punishment must follow. He wrote in Cur Dus Homo, that was just the name of his writing. Otherwise, God will not be just to himself. Sin became an unpaid invoice. The cross became the payment. Grace became a transaction with very specific terms. Then Calvin arrived. And where Anselm had built a balance sheet, Calvin built a decree. In his institutes, he doesn't just say God allows some to be lost. He says God arranges it. Individuals are born, he writes. Who are doomed from the womb to certain death and are to glorify him by that destruction. Read that sentence twice. It says some people are created for the specific purpose of being destroyed, and that their destruction brings God glory. The father's heart and the son's mercy get quietly severed from each other. God becomes a sovereign administrator instead of a father running down the road. And then in colonial America, Jonathan Edwards took all of that inherited architecture and turned it into a weapon aimed at the nervous system. The God that holds you over the pit of hell, he preached, much as one holds a spider, abhores you and is dreadfully provoked. He looks upon you as worthy of nothing else but to be cast into the fire. Conversion in this framing isn't a homecoming. It's a jailbreak from a God who is actively personally repulsed by you. Constantine, Augustine, Anselm, Calvin, Edwards, Empire, Guilt, Debt, Decree, Terror. Sixteen centuries, five men, one long, quiet remodel. And by the time it reaches us, it doesn't feel invented. It feels like it's just what the Bible says. That's the trick of it. Old and loud start to feel the same as ancient and true. Here's where it usually gets defended a chart. You've probably seen some version of it. Likely on social media. Progressive on one side, biblical on the other, and only one column gets to keep the label. It's presented as ancient orthodoxy. It isn't. It's the modern armor these five centuries built, laminated and handed out as if it came down from Sinai. So let's set the chart down and look at two stories instead. Real texts, not borrowed customs, no invented details. There's a man named Joshua in the book of Zechariah. Standing before God in filthy clothes, with the accuser standing right beside him, mid sentence listing every reason he doesn't belong there. And God doesn't argue the case. He doesn't even let the accusation finish. He simply says, Take off his filthy clothes, and then I will clothe you with festive robes. No debt calculated, no satisfaction demanded, just a robe offered before the argument for or against him is even resolved. And there's a son. In a story Jesus told, who rehearsed an entire confession on the walk home, a whole speech about not being worthy to be called a son anymore. He never gets to finish it. His father sees him from a long way off, while he's still just a shape on the horizon, and he runs. Quickly, the father says, Bring the best robe and put it on him. The robe comes before the apology lands. There's no courtroom in that scene at all. There is notably one person left standing outside in that story, the older brother, arms crossed in the dark, refusing to come in. But look closely at what keeps him out. It isn't the father. The father comes out to him too, still pleading. What keeps him out is his own certainty that the wrong person is getting a party he didn't earn. The darkness in that story isn't a punishment God hands down. It's a door somebody refuses to walk through with the light. And the music right there on the other side the entire time. That's worth sitting with. The Eastern Church has always just described God simply as light, not a being who occ occasionally withholds his love and calls the resulting absence hell, but light that never stops being offered. What we call darkness in that framework isn't God turning away. It's a soul that hasn't turned around yet. Which brings us to the phrase. That's been used to reinforce every one of these five men's systems. Many are called, but few are chosen. Calvin read chosen as a tiny cosmic VIP list, a small number handpicked for rescue, while everyone else was, in his words, born doomed to glorify God through destruction. But the older Hebraic sense of being chosen was never about a spatial evacuation plan. It was a vocation, an apprenticeship. You weren't chosen out of the world. You were chosen for it. Handed a towel instead of a getaway boat. Which brings us back to the soldiers guarding the tomb. That's what 16 centuries of courtroom theology finally produces. People standing guard over a story that was never meant to be locked down in the first place, convinced that keeping watch is the same thing as being faithful. It never was. The stone was already rolled away. There was never anything to guard. One more example, briefly, because it's the same pattern wearing modern clothes. In the 1830s, a man named John Nelson Darby began teaching something no church father, no medieval theologian, and no reformer had ever taught in the previous 18th centuries, that believers would be secretly removed from earth before a coming tribulation. It spread through a study Bible that sold millions of copies, then through a paperback in 1970 that outsold nearly every other nonfiction book of its decade. Then through a series of novels and films, most of us have actually seen. None of that makes it ancient. It makes it recent, successful, and very, very loud. So here's the real question underneath all five centuries of this. How much of what we've been calling just what the Bible says is actually just old and just loud? And if some of it turns out to be neither ancient nor true, is that something to grieve or something to finally quietly set down? Take off the armor, it was never actually. Your size. That's where we're going this week. And as questions start to form, hold on to them because we're gonna take breaks as we go to make room for everybody to to say what's on their heart, to share what's bubbling up on the inside. This is not a time for you to be shy. Because everybody in the room wants to hear what's on your heart because most likely they're thinking it too, and it just takes one brave person. I can't think of every possible answer that you might have a question for. So if we do this together, then we might be able to unfold some things. I loved last week. I loved hearing from the different voices in the room. Chelsea and I had a long conversation the other day about it. And it was so enlightening to hear more from her heart. It's just good for us to get comfortable with people who think differently than us. If that's uncomfortable for you, take a deep breath now. Because we're going there. Okay. We're gonna start with Constantine. That's where we started in reading the blog post. Western theology gradually replaced a relational therapeutic gospel with a legalistic courtroom model. And that all begins with Constantine, who legalized Christianity, not because he loved Christ, but because he saw it as gain. And this was a massive turning point for the way. In case you're wondering, that Is what they called it in the first century church. They were following the way. And we know because of the book of Acts that these people lived in community together and they shared all things in common. How do you take something that is so earthen, so naturally, and constitute it? It doesn't work. You take something that is grassroots and you legalize it, and it loses its permission to simply love, which is the entire point of the gospel, is that we simply receive love and reciprocate, reciprocate it. Yes? So this is not a doctrine from Constantine. It's a structural takeover. In one generation, the church went from persecuted minority to the empire's business partner. This was legalized by the Edict of Milan in 313 AD, made the actual state religion under Theodosius in 380 AD. This is the moment the gospel got welded to imperial hardware. And we read the quote from Constantine earlier, but I'll read again you are bishops of those within the church, but I have been appointed by God bishop of those outside. Can you see how dangerous this is when we when we trust the pure intention of Christ into the hands of somebody who's just looking to be a conqueror? That's dangerous. And I'm all for conquering hearts with love. But that's not this. Let's be realistic. I'll pause. Any questions? Thoughts? Concerns? Okay, we'll move on. Augustine of Hippo. He reinterpreted verses like Romans 5:12 through a flawed Latin translation. Augustine did not understand Greek, which is what he would have had access to, is Greek scriptures. And he tried to take something that he did not understand fully and interpret it into Latin, a language he did know. So we have a lot of misinterpretations. of Scripture, of the language within Scripture, because of Augustine. Now, does that make Augustine a bad guy? No. He's just flawed like the rest of us. We don't get everything right 100% of the time, even if we think we do. We just don't. Augustine didn't either. I think that his heart was right. And he does. We do have things today that Augustine said and did that are absolutely beautiful. But there are things that he translated, like Romans 5:12. And here's the major caveat. Is that each person is born already legally guilty of Adam's specific sin before committing any sin themselves? This is what he did to scripture like Romans 5 12, where he took it out of context and applied it in ways that it did not belong. So let me say this in terms that we can all understand. Next time you hold a fresh newborn, consider whether or not you actually believe that you're holding a flesh bag of sin. Are you actually capable of doing that? See, I think that we believe one thing in theory. But there's no way anybody in this room, and I know the majority of you, well enough to say, and I can even say by the looks on people's faces that like there's a there's an innocence in the people in the room that there's no way you could hold a fresh newborn and think to yourself, geez. This is just a pile of sin. But this is the translation that we get from Augustine. He shi it's slight, but he shifts it. And I'm sorry, but a good father. Who says, wow, it is very good on day six of creation, doesn't change his mind somewhere along the way, and then somehow damn newborns. That's crazy talk. But somehow we've kind of bought into it. And I don't even think it was accidentally, I just think that. That we get so good at regurgitating information, you know? Yeah. And so I think that there's some innocence in it, even in our part, just like Augustine's, where we're like, gosh, I guess that's just the truth. But I can tell you full well, none of the six babies that I pushed out did I hold immediately after and and feel some kind of warning concerning them. I'll tell you exactly what happened. There was such an overwhelming love that I didn't have words for it, only tears. And this baby who had no opportunity to earn that level of affection was receiving my love. And this is exactly how the father holds you. He does not look at you even now when your record is. A mess. Anybody in here got it all right? 'Cause I'll omit you. None of us have got it all right. The Father still holds us in that same way, holds you close. And the only thing that he can feel towards you is overwhelming love. Where I am convinced oftentimes the only thing he has is tears of joy. Because he's drawn near, because we've drawn near, 'cause he's always near. These things, these slight shifts that have gotten us so off course, so off course, to where we've taken something that is grassroots the way of following love and expressing love, and we've turned it into judgment. Where I get to stand up here and say, No, Jane, you missed it. Do you know in my hungriest days? Young, young, super young, my hungriest days, I'm asking everybody everywhere, tell me about Jesus. And do you want to know the majority of what I got back? This kind of stuff. Garbage. Hot steamy garbage. Telling me that I had to jump through hoops to get to God. And I'm sorry, but can you imagine how crushing that would feel for the Father? Ugh! If it feels like I'm a little passionate. Okay, here's a quote from Augustine. The whole mass of human race was under condemnation, was lying steeped and wallowing in misery, and was paying the well-merited penalty of the impious rebellious rebellion. Does this sound like somebody who understands the heart of the father? Yes. The whole mass of the human race was under condemnation, was lying steeped and wallowing in misery. And was paying the well-merited penalty of that impious rebellion. Can I just say, who do we think we are? Honestly, how arrogant that we would even be capable of forming such opinions about God and what he has done. John said this several months ago, but we actually put more faith in who we are in Adam than who we are in Christ. We have a greater faith for being the scum of the earth than we do as resurrected new creation life in Christ. And that's messed up. Can we be those who make much? Of the very good news of Jesus Christ. Can we be those who turn the ship around, not in arrogance, but in overwhelming love? Where we can be those whose arms are held out wide, and we're like, no, that's not it. Come over here, I'll show you. I'll show you how good he is. I will give my life away to prove to you how good he is. I can't go back. I can't do this any other way. I've tried. I've tried getting smart. That didn't work out. I've tried legalism. That really didn't work out. The gospel is for the broken. The gospel isn't for those who can pull themselves together and present themselves in such a way. The gospel belongs to those who know they need it. Let's move on to Anselm of Canterbury. He l he was living between 1033 and 1109. The feudal balance sheet was his his his big offering to society. He mapped 11th century feudal honor culture onto God. Offending an infinite king required infinite satisfaction to restore his honor. Can I just say as if? Like are we capable of restoring God's honor? All honor and glory and power belong to only one. There's no way you can take it away and there's no way that you can actually offer it up appropriately. This is the age he's living in. The feudal honor of kings. And they call it noble. Here's one of his quotes. The honor taken away must be repaid, or punishment must follow. Otherwise, either God will not be just to himself, or he will be weak. I'll read it again. The honor taken away must be repaid, or punishment must follow. Otherwise, either God will not be just to himself or he will be weak. Again, who do we think we are? We don't get to decide on God's behalf. who he is and how he gets to feel about things. Divine justice was redefined as a balance sheet of offended honor requiring proportional repayment. And this is the weight that we have lived under in our Western Christianity. Anybody ever felt guilt and condemnation in the midst of a church service? That's where lot of that comes from is this idea of feudal honor that I must offer him something. For my own restoration in his eyes. But here's here's the thing is you can't change what he thinks about you. You can't outsend God's goodness. It's impossible. He has not once changed his mind about who you are. When he declared it is very good, it was forever and ever and ever. It is a resonant declaration over all of humanity. You are very good. Even when you miss it, you are very good. And here's the hinge. It's his kindness that leads us where? To repentance. It's his kindness that causes us to turn around and agree with him. It's his kindness, not his anger, not his wrath. His kindness that causes us to turn back. if we're honest, we all go through trauma, we all go through pain, and we tend to form doctrine from that rather than what is true of God. We allow the trauma or the pain point to have too much of a say in what's going on. So we could go back to the the feudal honor piece that Anselm brought. And we know that he is in a dark space. You know, this is something that is in his culture, and but now he's taking what was in the culture and he's putting it on Christianity or on biblical principles. And so that's where it gets pulled out of context, is because he's taking his own culture, his own trauma, his own pain, and he's trying to form doctrine around it. But the the the the Point of the matter is that God doesn't shift from being good. Ever. He doesn't shift from being good. And this is this has gotten us into a lot of trouble because we we cherry pick scripture, number one, but we know that he's the same yesterday, today, and forevermore. So he's not shifting. He didn't change his mind about you. You changed your mind about him. The Bible actually tells us that we were only ever enemies in our minds. God didn't change his mind about us. Humanity changed their mind about God. We and us. We kept him at a distance. We said, You're too holy. Yeah, yeah. I mean have you ever heard the the phrase God can't look on sin? You guys, these are this is what I'm talking about. These cliche phrases that are tossed around like candy in a parade, they're rotting your soul. They're horrifying. God can't look on sin, then we're all doomed. We none of us have any hope if that's true. Let's go on to to John Calvin. Now we are in the fifteen hundreds at this point. His his work is is falls under the absolute the absolute decree of wrath. He codified penal substitutionary atonement. God didn't merely allow hell, He actively ordained some to it. Penal substitutionary atonement is just fancy language for what the Western Church actually believes is true. That Jesus was satisfying God's wrath. This is also where you kind of get the idea of God cannot look on sin. God turned his face away. While Jesus was hanging on the cross. This is what we've believed, and it is absolute what? Hogwash. That's a little more G rated. It's not true. We know full well that the Father was within the Son on the cross, reconciling the world to himself. That is what is true. I do know what the psalm says, so don't at me. Read the rest of it. We like to read just portions of things and we don't finish it because the psalm goes on. I know that David states that the father turns his face away. Read the rest of the psalm. And what we know is true is that the Father was in the Son. His only goal was to reconcile the entire cosmos to himself. He was after all. He wanted his kids back. I mean for those of you that are a parent. This hits harder to some. You want your kids back. And if you can feel that way, how much more the creator of that feeling? He wants his kids back. Yes, yes. Yes. Yes, and Jesus Jesus says it. He's like, which one of you would give your kid a snake instead of a fish? Or a stone instead of bread? How much more is my father in heaven better than you? That's this whole point. Where do you think that came from? That in ache. I want my kids back. That's what was going on on the cross. Just want my kids back. He's a good father. That's not just cliche phraseology. He's good. To his core, he's good. John Calvin, penal substitutionary atonement. He basically took feudal honor and injected it with steroids. For real. And and made it so that John Calvin actually took this idea of the elect, that there were some people who were elect to be saved, and then there are some people who are elect to damnation. And this is where the idea of eternal conscious torment comes into play, where we start to have to grapple with that too. Not only is God iffy on us, but now He wants to burn people for all eternity. And some never had the option to sin or not. You see how muddled this gets? How messy it gets when you start layering it on top of each other? It's a hot mess. It is my humble opinion that eternal conscious torment is also hogwash. A good father is not capable of such torment. This is man made doctrine. Here's a quote. Individuals are born who are doomed from the womb to certain death and are to glorify him by their destruction. Want me to read it again? Individuals are born who are doomed from the womb to certain death and are to glorify him by their destruction. Good father category? No. It's awful. Quite awful. I wanted to read an e excerpt out of out of my own book. This is a shameless plug. But I just said it so well. When I first encountered the logic of offended honor, I didn't realize I was being handed a feudal contract instead of a father's invitation. The grimacing news, hinging on luck, felt more like a game of roulette where my heart was the currency and the rigged requirements were in play. Total offense. This Roman shift was first formalized in the eleventh century by a theologian named Anselm Canterbury. Living in a world of feudal lords and rigid social hierarchies, Anselm argued that human sin had offended God's honor, and like a debt to a king it required a satisfaction that only a divine death could provide. Are we good? This birthed the doctrine known as penal substitutionary atonement. It presented the image of an angry God who just needed to hit something, a divine judge whose holy rage was so combustible that it had to be diverted onto a substitute to keep the universe from imploding. Centuries later, the reformers, particularly John Calvin, expanded and cemented this legal framework. Although I can survey my past and detect where this mindset revealed itself, I didn't formally encounter the system until recently. The introduction was cold and arrogant, a clinical attempt to get me saved, although I had been in ministry for over twenty years. In that environment, my experience of walking with the Father was irrelevant. My inability to recite the Tulip Doctrine was presented as the only evidence of my doom. Calvin, who was himself trained as a lawyer, took Anselm's offended honor and turned it into divine jurisprudence. Calvin's legal framework is brilliant if you're a lawyer, but it's suffocating if you're a daughter. It's the reason my shoulders used to hunch in corporate times of prayer. I was bracing for deposition, not a conversation. In Calvin's view, God was the supreme legislator, and the cross was the supreme courtroom. He argued Christ had to absorb God's holy anger against sin, diverting the outpouring from us onto himself. This suggests that Blood must be spilled to appease God. This is where the legalized gospel became the very air we breathe in the West, reducing our oxygen, leaving us aching for fresh wind beyond the smog of religion. It is why so many of us spend our lives white knuckling a grip on grace. A lawyer has trained us to approach a father as if he were a judge. This is precisely why you nervously visit the porch with your legal briefs tucked under your arm, ready to legislate your right to be there. While the traditional frameworks of substitution or ransom have been used for centuries to explain this moment, they often fail to capture the full staggering weight of the wreckage. The cross was not a legal settlement to appease a distant God. It was the Father's ultimate, I am here, in the middle of our self-made hell. He didn't send Jesus to pay a debt, he was holding it against us. He came in Christ to absorb the violence we were holding against ourselves. It wasn't about a judge getting his due. It was about a father getting his children back. We are at we were at our absolute worst, so colonized by the knowledge of good and evil that when love made flesh walked into the room without a ledger, we didn't know how to receive him. In our delusion, a love like Christ's made little sense. It was a threat to the only system of control we knew. The cross exposed the religious worst in the Pharisee who needed a rule to feel safe. It exposed the political worst in the leader who needed power to feel secure. And it exposed the internal worst in all of us, the part of the human soul that would rather kill love than accept a seat it didn't earn. But the Father answered our violence with a reality that was, as Paul writes in Romans 5, out of all proportion to the trespass. The audit is a one-to-one accounting. It demands an eye for an eye. But the gift is not like the debt. If our worst was capable of killing love, the Father's response was a landslide of grace that didn't just cover an offense, it buried the entire geography of our rebellion and raised us up in life full tilt. God saw the wreckage of our ability to even want him. He knew that the only way to reach us was to let our violence spin itself on his own heart. He entered our darkest hour not to satisfy an offended ego. But to witness our wreckage and blow the doors off the prison from the inside. So that we could see shadow boxing a judge and start receiving a nonsensical, unearned love that is, frankly, completely intimidating to a mind that still wants to pay its own way, he died. The gift is so massive that it doesn't just pay the debt, it bankrupts the entire system of debt itself. When you finally step onto the porch, The fire of God doesn't consume you, it consumes the paperwork. It incinerates every stale clinical legal brief you brought to prove your worthiness, leaving only the unadorned indivisible child. Like I said, I feel a little passionate on the topic. But can you see how we've got it so twisted? I don't want us to have it twisted anymore. It's what holds us hostage to a small life, to a jack-in-the-box life. Jeff and I are talking about the jack-in-the-box life. You know, you get excited, you get wound up, you pop up, I can do this, I can do this. And then wham, life happens. And it's this back and forth toggle between I can do this, I can do this. No, I cannot. And the truth is, no, you cannot. But he can. Christ in me is the hope of glory. Christ in you is the hope of glory. And what this means is the revelation of Christ in humanity is the hope of glory. The Old Testament prophets talked about a day when the glory of the Lord would fill the whole earth like the waters cover the seas. Where on earth do you think the glory is gonna come from? It's not some magical downpour of glory. It's coming from you. You are a glory dispenser. God loves you like crazy. And once you actually be believe that, the glory is just gonna start leaking out. Happens all the time. I I told you Ted was making rules on Friday. about this being a place of celebration and I quite liked it, even though I tease him. And Kevin and I were having a conversation in the midst of the the celebration and and Kevin said something along the lines of, you're calling me a liar. And Ted goes, Don't say that word in here. But this was glory leaking. This is glory moments. This is when the hope of glory starts coming out of someone because they believe with their whole being that God made me to celebrate. Now we could all have been having a very bad day and come into Ted's presence, and you know what that feels like? Hot cools. It does. If you're having a no good, terrible, very bad day and somebody is just like, it's super obnoxious and you're like, can you just go away? But you know what's happening? Their hope of glory is messing with your hope deferred. Their hope of glory is messing with your hope deferred. Proverbs tells us that hope deferred makes the heart sick. Most of us stop there. We don't read the rest of the verse. Hope deferred makes the heart sick, but a fulfilled longing is the tree of life. You have a choice between trees. Hope deferred comes from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. fulfilled longing comes from the tree of life. One is Jesus, one is humanity in the mess. And I used to like, not not like, you know, like those moments where it's not like a complete thought, but you know that you you have you hold this belief. And for me, like the tree of the knowledge of good and evil on one side was the good fruit and on the other side of the tree was the bad fruit. Anybody? Maybe you didn't actually put it in terms like that, but it but you think in it. Like, no, I just let you see it from this side over here with it where it's good. It's one kind of fruit on the whole tree. Stay away. It's not doing anything for you. Tree of life, tree of life, fulfilled longing. Don't allow yourself to be mixed up in missing the moment where glory is leaking into the space because you're in a bad mood. And I'm not saying that you can't have bad days. Have bad days, but let the leaking glory fix it. Okay? All right, the modern artifact. This is where we get to those who are still playing guard at the tomb. And when I talked about this when I was reading the blog, where we have these two charts, and we see most of these put out on social media, and I find them highly obnoxious because it's just very Yesterday when we were reading Ephesians, we were talking about all kinds of social issues and it applied. And I was sitting there and I was thinking through it and I'm like, My gosh, social issues are layers deep. And what you and I see at face value is the best case scenario of the social issue. That's what these charts are like. They they wanna they wanna make it so like staunch and it's just so clear and it's so plain, but it's not. It's not, and most of the biblical side of the chart falls under some of the trash we've been reading about, if I'm honest. And so it's usually biblical versus progressive, and this is what Most people are standing guard over. If you are still a soldier standing guard at a tomb where the stone is already rolled away and it is empty, I want you to just simply ask yourself what is it exactly that I'm guarding and protecting? It's not Jesus. He ain't there. And I think some of us even go further and we insert ourselves into the tomb. I'm just dying for Christ. I know I've told many of you this story before, but I had this encounter years and years ago where I was brought into the middle of this tomb and it was a crowd. I mean, they were like it was wall to wall, crowded in this tomb, like crowded. And there was just like all this kind of like almost whimpering going on called prayer. But it it there was no hope in it. It was just like what was me kind of prayer. And over the top of all of it was this booming voice of my father saying, I am not there, I am risen. And he didn't stop there. He came in with that father kind of authority, and he's like, You are not there. You are risen. See, most of us still live our lives like we are tombdwellers. We keep trying to resurrect. the what God put to death in Adam. You are not there. You are risen. New life has been given you. I dare you to test it. You are limitless. Christ is within. You are in him. It's a mystery. I don't know what it all means, but I sure am leaning in. I love mystery. I love revelation. I love leaning into things and wanting to know Tell me more. Say more about that, Jesus. I think we lost. Jonathan Edwards, and this will be the final one. So if you're getting wiggly, you're okay. This is 1703 to 1758. American terror as convert as a conversion engine. He embedded a psychological trigger into American folk theology. Panic as proof of genuine faith. Panic as proof. Of genuine faith. Anybody been there? Anybody answered all 1,000 altar calls in your life? That's panic as proof. In his own words, and this is the most gruesome of them all the God that holds you over the pit of hell, much as one holds a spider, abhores you and is dreadfully provoked. He looks upon you as worthy of nothing else but to be cast into the fire. And this comes from his book, Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God. The title alone, Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God, is in complete defiance of the gospel because God would never refer to you that way. And He doesn't have angry hands. His hands are for holding you, drawing you, shaping you, molding you. He's not angry. And he is certainly not holding you over a fire. God is trying to prove your worth. He's already installed it. You're worthy. He is trying his very best to prove it. He has robed you in righteousness. And like Zechariah says of Joshua, I'm going to take off your dirty rags and I'm going to put on new garments. You didn't do that. God did. In your best effort to dress yourself, you look lousy. But God redressed you in robes of righteousness. You belong in his presence at his table. You are a child of the living God. This Jonathan Edwards quote is where youth group gets its idea of bonfires and salvation calls. Turner Byrne. We're scaring our youth to death and calling it salvation. When are we going to trust that he's actually good? That I can actually just lead with. He's just so good and he loves you. Jane, do you come here because God's good and the people loved you? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And Jane's Jane's story is just one of many. So many people come and go in here and we don't take attendance, so come and go, I don't care. But they do so because of the love and the acceptance. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, we're just redistributing what's been given to us for free. It's all free. It's all free gift. A big, ridiculous, outlandish free gift that you cannot earn. Not even on your best day. So stop trying. Just receive it. I did have one final point because we talked about rapture early on. The the rapture theory has also crept into Western culture and has done a lot of damage. In fact, I would say that it's responsible for shutting down the entire Jesus movement, which would have been in the 60s and 70s, because the people got so wackadoo that they stopped caring about all kinds of things, all kinds of responsibilities because it didn't matter because they They were going to raptured. And they started wearing tinfoil on their head. I tell you, it was weird. Weird, weird, weird, weird, weird stuff. But this material sold like hotcakes. You are not going to find rapture theory in scripture anywhere. It's not in there. This is where our escapism mentality has come into play, where I'm just biding time for the sweet buy and buy. I'm just, I'm just waiting it out until I go home to glory. News flash. You earthling were made for earth. The idea that we're all going to sit on clouds like little fat cherubs playing odd instruments is fictional. It's not real. And even the idea of heaven up there and out there, like there's some kind of intersection between heaven and earth that we have to get across the seven-lane highway to get there. Also a farce. Heaven and earth are commingling right now. Where the presence of the Father is, there his kingdom is also. He is at hand. He's as close as your next breath. Heaven here, now, not earned by death. I don't know who coined the phrase, but if you're waiting for death, then that becomes your savior. Salvation now, heaven now, reward now. Eternal life now. The moment that you had the aha, Christ is inside of me, He is the hope of glory wiggling around in my belly. Is the moment that you realized that you are surrounded by all of heaven. We've got a crazy thought about escapism. I just gotta get off this planet. Well, you're made for this planet. You're made for here. Live your best life to the full here. Infect as many people as possible. By the hope of glory. Will we all die? Well, the Bible actually says that some won't. Some won't. Some won't die. They'll just continue on. Death is not your savior. Stop trying to escape. Your body is gift. It's a great gift, beautiful gift. Thank you, Jesus, that I have a heart that's beating and pumping right now. Thank you, God, for the blood that's flowing through my veins. Thank you for eyesight. Thank you for vocal cords, for the ability to smell, to sense, thank you for emotion. Our bodies have to stop being looked at as if they're just Broken. I mean we have pains. Things hurt. Right? I am whole. I'm a glory dispenser. Start thinking about yourself differently. I'm a glory dispenser. And I am loved. A Pez dispenser, I know. Some of us some of us in the room went to a Christian school and we were actually we had to sit down and watch a series called Hell's Bells. And we had to learn about all the evils that are in every industry. We had to listen to records backwards. Just to hear Natas Satan backwards. This honestly was my introduction to Christianity. I was raised Catholic. And this was this was my introduction to Christianity was doom. Hell. I can sincerely tell you that I had a better relationship with my father prior to my introduction to Christianity. Everything went from this colorful, affectionate relationship that I had with him. To gray mush, like I suddenly didn't get it, and it was very fearful. I was so afraid that I wasn't doing it right, that I didn't know enough, that I had to somehow do something more. Always there was always something more that had to be accomplished to outrun. The Satan who is hot on my trail. What are you sure? Worse, batter. I mean it's just I and this is this is Western Christianity. It's what so many people were brought up under. Robin and I were having a conversation and I told her I was like, so I I was reading through the comments of a post that caught my attention on the socials. And I love reading comments because I love hearing people's hearts on things. And I came across one that said something along the lines of, because the post was on hell. And I don't want to get into an argy about that this morning. But the post was on hell, and one of the commenters, and it was kind of off the wall, it didn't really have anything to do with anything, but he says, If you're saying that hell is not real, then Jesus isn't a savior. And I I mean, it took me back. I mean, I was it knocked me out. I was like, what? What does this even mean? And so I was telling Robin about it. I was like, I don't understand this. Like, I don't know this gospel. I didn't know that people actually thought that Jesus was saving us from doom in hell. I always knew that he was saving us from ourselves. I didn't know that there was this whole thought process, this whole belief that we were actually the he did what he did to save us from burning forever. I just didn't know. This was just a couple weeks ago, in case you're wondering. And she goes, Angie, that's what most of us are raised on. I sincerely, my heart was so sad. So sad that that's what so many people walk through and carry that like Jesus did what he did so you don't burn. No, he did what he did because he likes you. They did what they did because they wanted you back. Take hell out of that picture for a second. They did what they did because they wanted you desperately. It had nothing to do with a threat. That's not love. That's control. Cross isn't a threat. It's an offering. Beautiful gift. All right, I've said enough. Anybody have anything to say? Questions? Comments? I'll give you time to let things percolate. It is. Yeah. And mostly innocent. I mean, it's not like anybody set out to be like, let's mess up the entire Western theology. Like, nobody did that. Nobody did that. They thought they were doing right. It's the same as Paul, our beloved Paul from the Bible. He once killed Christians. He thought he was doing God's bidding. These people did too. When you and I have missed it and we've put something in place over others to control them, we weren't doing it because we didn't love them. We were did it because we didn't get it. So I'm not like, this isn't Angie going like, ooh, those guys are bad. No, their thinking was bad. They just didn't know God. And we started this whole thing off by saying, what you believe about God is the most important thing about you. And it's true. Because it will dictate how you approach everything in your life. And everyone. Thank you, sir. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Well, you know, to to the best of our ability, our six kids were raised in this version of the gospel, and they are more free than I'm comfortable with because I wasn't brought up in that same freedom. And so for me, I I want to put parameters and guards and boundaries on it, but they they are they're f they are so free. I mean they have d and I'm not saying that they're there. They've not arrived. That's not don't misunderstand me. And they still have hang-ups. I'm not saying they're perfect. I'm just saying the Freedom that they live in is like, am I, I mean, right? It's wild. I it did not come from me. I was not free. I was very, I still am. I'm very, I'm a black and white kind of person. I I I tend to be more right-wrong. But I've learned. The way of God is different. Love looks different than just right wrong. But yeah, I mean it is profound. It's profound to see the effect of a gospel that seeded freedom in our kids looks like. And and some of the some of the other kids that that they grew up in, I'm telling you. There is so th the nature of this message and and Jeff can jump in 'cause I know we've had this conversation and a Robin When people find out that he's not the rule enforcer. And the gospel is a free gift, and that God isn't measuring and weighing them. A lot of people kind of go off the rails, right? I mean, like they they test it, they test the boundaries, like how far can I go? And it's it's not a license to sin, but freedom from sin. And but a lot of people are like, ooh, this gospel's awesome. God's gonna love me no matter what. And that is true. But we don't actually have to go out and try and prove it. We one of our friends who was a pastor, he said, you know, you stick your hand in a blender, it's gonna hurt. You know, the the wages of sin are death. Sin pays you in death. So this is why sin not. Not so that you can appear some certain way before God, that's not the goal. It's because it hurts. It pays in death. What? It's bad for you. It's bad for you. But if you if you do find yourself, just lean into his kindness. It'll take care of it all. Yeah. Right. Yeah, I mean I suppose it was an effective scare tactic. Be good so God will like you? What? They know things. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. And she was she I don't know why the happened. And I put my hands on and sh we thought she had a stroke because she was like I put her in the hand, what is this? If I make my bed in hell, there you are also. is so funny. Yeah. Jess is like, let's get the story straight. Let's get the story straight, Levonda. Yep. Yep. It's true. It does. It does, Bryn. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So Yeah. No one can Yeah. Yeah, there he's hands out. With this maybe like Renewed Mind. Renewed mind. Yeah. Renewed mind. Yeah. And the thing is, is you can read anything into the Bible. You really can. You can interpret it any way that you want. This is why what you believe about God is the most important thing about you. Because it becomes a lens. And that's how you take everything in, even the Bible. So if you're reading the Bible and you feel like there's a finger wagging at you in judgment and you want to just slam it shut and throw it. Well, what you believe about God has some missing ingredients, you know? Because he's good. He's good. Yeah. I just want I want everybody to recognize the giddiness. There's like this element of giddy in the room right now, and that is the entryway into freedom where you have this overwhelming joy that's starting to surface, and it is the evidence of good news. We need to understand the difference between so-so news and good news. Good news produces joy. So so news produces condemnation. No. No. Yes. Amen. Amen. All right. I keep catching that that plant waving its little hands and I think that somebody's like, I've got something to say. I think it's because it's how it's sitting in front of the glass that it's I don't know, it's a weird weird moment for me. Anyway, Father God, thank you. Loving us, thank you for including us in all that you have done, and thank you for extending your goodness over us, through us, all around us, and for bringing us into the ooey-gooey center of your love. Amen.